How Ontario McGuinty gov’t failing students

Worth repeating: If the Progressive Conservative Mike Harris government had tried to do to the Ontario education system what the Liberal McGuinty government is currently doing, the teachers’ unions and all those who agreed with their anti-government stance, would have protested for days on end — all covered  by a supportive liberal media.

Yet, all we read or hear that questions the current Liberal government’s so-called “Success Strategy” is from some retired teachers, a few media journalists (e.g., Moira MacDonald at the Toronto Sun) and some concerned citizens and bloggers (e.g., regular readers Ann, Educ8m and Skinny Dipper). 

And, what do educators and the public hear from the McGuinty government? They get a very defensive written response from the Deputy Minister of Education, Ben Levin.

 Now, while I would agree that Mr. Levin’s letter is articulate and systematic in his defence of the “no-fail” policy, he is far from convincing. Why? Because most of his points of defence are based on unsubstantiated assumptions.

Mr. Levin does, for instance, frequently claim an issue is supported by empirical evidence. Yet, we are never told what that evidence is and under what conditions the research was conducted (e.g., the methods used). In other words, simply saying something has been shown to be good or helpful in certain circumstances does not mean that conclusion should be generalized to an entire education system.

Moreover, as a former educational researcher and academic, I know, for example, that you can prove just about anything you want as long as you identify your limitations and assumptions. So, simply saying empirical evidence suggests this or that is a very slippery slope.

As a result, at the end of the day, the Ontario government’s arguments are just more political spin meant to convince everyone that all is well — trust us, don’t worry, be happy.

Well, we should be worried because no amount of spin can cover up the  allegations being made that the current Ontario government is destroying the Ontario education system with their failing “no-fail” policy.

And, why are the McGuinty Liberals pushing this policy so hard? Because they promised during the fall 2007 provincial election, that if re-elected, they would increase the graduation rates, while simultaneously decreasing the drop out rates. Problem is, they didn’t say how they would do it.

The crux of the matter is that if the current relativistic “seldom or never fail” policy keeps up, guaranteed, we will soon have illiterate and/or unprepared high school graduates competing for jobs and post-secondary admissions with graduates who completed all their work and deserved to graduate.

My message to the McGuinty government and Mr. Levin: By all means, implement policies that help students “succeed.” No one would ever quibble with that concept. But, please do not do it by generalizing the acceptance of substandard work because the students you think you are helping now will only fail later.

Note: To get at the core issues, read MendEd’s latest post and the Little Education Report.

H/T Ann.

2 thoughts on “How Ontario McGuinty gov’t failing students

  1. ’empirical evidence’ only means that someone at OISE said it or had a fantasy about it, reality is entirely different than post-modern ’empirical evidence’.


  2. I’ve hired several co-op students from universities over the last several years. One thing that seems to be declining is the ability to write proper sentences and paragraphs in formal reporting.

    Sometimes I wonder if this is a symptom of these types of policies.

    Ironically, one of the best reports I’ve read recently was written by a bilingual student from Quebec. The ESL training must really be working well.

    I’m glad I’ll be long dead when the written English language finally bites the dust.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.