Is the DSBN Academy going to be like a KIPP school?

A Google search indicates that a lot has been written about the recent decision by the District School Board of Niagara (DSBN) to approve a Grade 6 – 12 school (to be called the DSBN Academy) for disadvantaged kids from families where no one has ever graduated from a post-secondary institution. Here also is what Hugo at The Education Reporter has written — as well as here and here. Now, while I haven’t read anywhere that it will be based on the U.S.  KIPP model  — Knowledge is Power — it sounds like that is the DSBN rationale.

KIPP schools are unapologetically post-secondary preparation schools for children and youth who would not likely make it otherwise. And, they apparently are very successful.  In fact, I have written very positively about KIPP schools before.  However, there are some major differences between KIPP schools and what will be the DSBN Academy.

For example, KIPP schools, as far as I understand them, are within specific communities.  So, the problem with the DSBN Academy is that it will be in Welland. Meaning, that kids will have to be bussed from Grimsby, Fort Erie, St. Catharines, Thorold, Niagara Falls and Niagara-on-the-Lake — all huge distances from Welland. Like special education, that will mean a two to three-hour round trip by bus each and every single day — miles and miles from their own communities, friends and family.

Instead, then, why doesn’t the DSBN simply implement the proven Pathways program as suggested by Brock professor, Kevin Gosine, in this Standard article. What is especially positive about Pathways is that it can be implemented in each and every neighbourhood school. I mean, it is hardly fair to parents and taxpayers to provide special programs and services at only one school when there will be hundreds, if not thousands of kids, not able to participate.    

But, the major problem it seems is that the DSBN did not hold public consultations, and I mean public, not just with stakeholder groups that were in favour of the concept. As many regulars here know, I nearly ran for public school board trustee in the Ontario, October municipal election and even when I didn’t, I followed things very carefully. I heard nothing whatsoever about a possible DSBN Academy. The DSBN administration is now claiming that “Project Connect” was openly discussed at all-candidates nights. Well, who would ever connect “Project Connect” to a new school? No one who didn’t know anything about it, that is for sure.

Well, a newly elected Niagara-on-the-Lake trustee by the name of Jonathan Fast, has put forward a motion for the DSBN to cancel the DSBN Academy approval — and, according to this Niagara Advance editorial,  that vote will be this coming Tuesday. Will the decision be rescinded? I doubt it because far too many decisions have already been made and certain reputations are at stake. However, given the political pressure, one never knows. Stay tuned!

4 thoughts on “Is the DSBN Academy going to be like a KIPP school?

  1. Is this going to be a school for poor and disadvantaged children?

    If so, does it not add to their stigma to be singled out, segregated or does this protect them from the society we hope they’ll all be part of when they graduate?


  2. Liz J — That is exactly what it is and at the start of the public discussion it was referred to as a school for “poor” children. But, after a great deal of flack, the DSBN changed that to “those whose families have no one who ever completed post-secondary.” I didn’t write about it — but the labelling will be horrendous. All they will have to say is they graduated from the DSBN Academy (no matter how old they are in life) and everyone will know they were disadvantaged. Which is why some are saying it is going to be education aparteid and segregation.

    My complaint is that kids need to be exposed to all types of kids, rich ones, poor ones, black, white, male, female, the whole range — because that is the society they will enter once they get to the post-secondary context.

    However, all that said, when you check out KIPP schools in the U.S., they are wonderful. I don’t know how they do it, frankly but the stigma does not seem to be there. Perhaps it is because in the U.S., there are entire communities that are considered disadvantaged. In Canada, apart from a couple of communities in Toronto, are mixed in terms of demographics.

    Anyway, thanks for reading that post. You hit the nail on the head as it were.


  3. Mary T– Yes, that is a great poll but that was a week before the ODA fiasco. It is my hope that the polls will actually go up even more to show the opposition that this nonsense doesn’t work. But, by the same token, if the polls go down, it will reinforce that nasty does work. Time will tell. We need a few days for the truth to get out.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.