“School choice” not elitist as some politicians in York Region contend!

The notion of school choice has been around for quite a while. Usually, the term refers to school district policies that allow parents, who are public school supporters, to choose the school their children attend. Choice, in terms of independent private schools is, of course, the ultimate choice, but one few can afford.

Well, the notion of publicly funded choice is back in the news. Usually, in Ontario at least, those “choices” are referred to as alternative or specialty schools. However, as Moira MacDonald of the Toronto Sun wrote yesterday, it seems that a group of parents in York Region are “squaring off against trustees wanting to eliminate specialty schools at the elementary level.”

MacDonald also laments, rightly, that too often school trustees (and I would add union officials) refer to the specialty public schools as “boutique” schools — more as a putdown than anything else.

For example, a quick Google search indicates that the definition of boutiques are small fashionable stores geared towards special clients — meaning that alternative schools are just as elitist, which is hardly the case if an alternative school has an Africentric curriculum or is geared towards students with special learning needs.

As MacDonald writes about her own high school experience:”‘Boutique school’ wasn’t yet in vogue when I attended an alternative high school in Scarborough. Instead, we got slammed as ‘elitist.’ Here’s how elitist we were: We were black, brown, white, Chinese, gay, poor, middle-class, drop-out risks, kids from single-parent homes and kids from two-parent homes.'”

So, what is really going on when opponents of choice put down the very idea of parent choice within a publicly funded education system? In my opinion, it is related to what I was writing about yesterday, the problem with today’s progressives. They are more conservative than Conservatives: rigid, intolerant of differences and change of any kind, as well as requiring complete uniformity of experience and outcome. 

Interesting, I came across an article today in Macleans that confirms the role reversal between progressives and liberals and conservatives. It was titled: “Which political party is really rigid and inflexible?” While it wasn’t about school choice, it did show why it is likely that the Ontario Liberal government, the Ontario teachers’ unions and trustees for York Region, are suffering from the same kind of fear of change and differences.

Anyway, the crux of the matter is that I am 100% with the York Region parents on this one. It is not elitist to give children and youth a choice of what school they want to attend.

4 thoughts on ““School choice” not elitist as some politicians in York Region contend!

  1. Sandy – the progressives (and this includes the teachers’ unions) are the elitist ones. They see themselves as experts, far more qualified than mere parents to guide and direct (and indoctrinate) today’s children. Their public expression shows a lot of disdain for parents, but I sense there is also a certain amount of fear that expanding parental choice will expose the total lack of accountability in today’s teaching profession.

    This is a shame. I know a lot of excellent and caring teachers, but they are stiffled by the bureaucracy as well as political correctness. We need to clean house at the bureaucratic level and take a hard look at the curriculum (with real people and not just soi-dissant experts involved). Then we have to look at standards. It’s a complex process, but students and teachers alike deserve better.


  2. Ditto for me Frances. Do we have any leader of any party currently that will do this?
    Nope. Although, I do believe that Dalton McGuinty is going to be forced to try….just like the others before him. He’s got to make cuts to education somewhere, and he’s going to get Don Drummond to be the bad guy who delivers the BAD, BAD news.


  3. I just left the following comment on the other current thread:

    Please note that I had to change my theme/template today because it was causing problems (as did the last one). I had things programmed so that there were no more than five posts on the Home page at any one time. However, what was happening is that you had to scroll through every post I had ever written before you got to the bottom of the page. Frustrating to say the least.

    The comment feature on this latest theme is a little different, however, in that you have to click on a little dialogue bubble at the top right side of each post.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.